The Gauhati High Court has stressed that "bulldozing of a house is not provided under any criminal law", even if an agency is investigating a "very serious matter".
Gauhati HC Lashes Out At ‘Bulldozer Justice’ Trend, Shuns It As ‘Gang War’ Where ‘Nobody Is Safe’
Chief Justice RM Chhaya made the observation while hearing a suo motu case regarding demolition using bulldozers of at least six houses purportedly in search of weapons and drugs hidden beneath the structures.
Bulldozed houses in Nagaon, Assam
Bulldozed houses in Nagaon, Assam
HC took suo motu cognisance?
Chief Justice RM Chhaya made the observation on Thursday, while hearing a suo motu case taken up by the high court regarding demolition of the house of an accused in Batadrava Police Station arson case in Nagaon district of Assam.
The Batadrava Police Station was set on fire on May 21 by an irate mob following the alleged custodial death of a local fish trader, Safikul Islam (39), who was picked up by police the night before.
A day later, the district authorities had bulldozed at least six houses, including Islam’s, purportedly in search of weapons and drugs hidden beneath the structures.
‘We are in a democratic set-up’
"Even if a very serious matter is being investigated by an agency, bulldozing of a house is not provided under any criminal law," Justice Chhaya observed.
Emphasising that it requires permission to even search a house, he said, "Tomorrow if you need something, you will dig up my court room. "How can you do it? You can be anybody. Nobody is safe… under guise of investigation if you pull down anybody’s house," the chief justice added.
He pointed out that a search warrant is required, adding, "We are in a democratic set-up". "In a lighter vein, even Lord Macaulay could not have thought of it and he is a giant on criminal law," he said.
Maintain law and order: Chief Justice
Pointing out that one 0.9 mm pistol was recovered by demolishing the house, as submitted in the government affidavit, Chief Justice Chayya also raised apprehension that it could have been planted also.
He maintained that incidents of such bulldozing of houses are done in movies, and even in those, the search warrant is shown before the act. The chief justice equated the bulldozing of the houses to an act in a ‘gang war’ and asked the Home department to find better ways of carrying out their investigation.
"There is a purpose why ‘law and order’ words are used together…this is not the manner in which law and order is controlled," he added.
The court later listed the matter for December 12.
(With inputs from PTI)
-
Previous Story
.jpg?auto=format%2Ccompress&fit=max&format=webp&w=376&dpr=2.0)
Post-Polls, J&K Assembly To Pass Resolution For Restoring Special Status And Statehood -
Next Story
Delhi: Traffic Cops Suspended After CCTV Footage Of Collecting, Splitting Bribe Goes Viral
